Saturday, August 22, 2020

The Democrat’s Dilemma

    Joe Biden’s acceptance speech on Thursday night was by any measure perfect for the man and for the moment. It was delivered with compassion but also with clarity of purpose offering the electorate a clear choice between the dystopic vision offered by Donald Trump and a vision of hope for deliverance from the darkness of Trump’s message and the chaos and brutality of the past three years. It is a message that should resonate with everyone...not only with the Democratic base but those who call themselves independents and claim to withhold judgment until compelled to choose. 

        Despite the eloquence of Mr. Biden’s message it certainly did not and never will resonate with Trump’s base (so smitten with the mythic Trump that they collectively fail to realize the damage he has and will continue to reign down on their lives and their futures) and while one would hope that independents would grasp onto the life preserving message offered by Mr. Biden, the likelihood of their doing so is not so clear. While Trump’s governance and his message is clearly based upon dividing the nation and giving license to unleashing the very worst of human nature, the Republican message is more nuanced, continuing to target the grievances of so-called, “Middle America” that brought Trump far more votes in 2016 from the middle of the country, in particular, than anyone could have imagined could be cast for such damaged and dangerous human being. While those targeted may have legitimate grievance, particularly this year with so much familial and economic hardship impacting so many, including those considered to be favoring a continuation of the Trump presidency, the GOP seeks to convince the undecided electorate that, at least for “White America”, the Democratic message of inclusiveness is itself actually a message of division and exclusion, seizing upon concern heard throughout conservative media that by embracing the Black Lives Matter movement, the Democratic party has actually become anti-white. The Republicans will pull from Biden’s speech his eloquent plea for racial justice and seek to convince those they target that those passages and the notion itself is proof positive that a BIden presidency will be so focused upon social and racial justice that “White America” will be at risk of being left behind; that the policies to be enacted by a Biden administration will be pursued at the expense of “white” interests and that, in truth, there is no room in the large, Democratic “house” for “White America”. They will point to Biden’s selection of Kamala Harris as his running mate and argue that with Biden’s advanced age, there is a real chance that Ms Harris will become President during Biden’s four year term and that if that comes to pass she will pursue with even greater vigor policies that favor minorities the expense of white interests. 

        It is a dangerous strategy to say the least. The last four months of protests triggered in the immediate sense by the murder of George Floyd but truly a continuation of the struggle for equality that has been ever-present for more than the past one hundred and sixty years. The impact of those protests has been immediate, evidenced not only by the millions of people who have taken to the streets but by the response of corporate America to those protests. While many would argue that the response of corporations to the BLM movement is driven by greed (which is certainly is) it nevertheless should not be lost on anyone that so-called “Corporate America” made a choice to not remain silent; that when it spoke through its marketing message it was entirely on the side of social justice. Moreover, again at the risk of giving corporations too much credit, it is also worth noting that campaign contributions by corporations and their management to the presidential candidates favors Mr. Biden, driven, in large part, by their determination that their best interests lie in acknowledging and embracing Mr. Biden’s plea for social justice for it is that message which most clearly reflects the will of the people. 

        The challenge faced by the Democrats over the next two months will be to continue to speak to those people who may view the call for social and racial justice as either anti-white or exclusive of “white interests” that their interests are best served when everyone has an equal chance for happiness and security; that the chant of Black Lives Matter does not mean that White lives don’t matter despite what they might hear from Fox News, OANN or Breitbart. The task will regrettably not be an easy one. The stakes of failure are unimaginably high for a furtherance of a Trump administration, unleashed by a re-election will without question be the end of the American experiment if the last four years are any measure. One can only hope that despite the efforts of the right and its puppet media the voters either do not accept the dystopic product they are trying to sell or simply have had enough of the daily chaos and that their longing for a moment’s silence wins out.